Ep. 53 | She's NOT a Top Performer: The Mistake Leaders Make.
Your highest-producing employee refuses to delegate, never comes to team day, and has become the office joke. Is she still your top performer?
In Part 2 of the Arcadia conversation, Heather Cooper and Blakely Graham bring more anonymous Sticky Situations home from the Arcadia Leadership Experience (https://www.arcadialeadershipexperience.com/) in Bozeman. They explain why individual output is not the same as leadership, why special rules for one star employee can wreck a culture, and how a manager can hold someone accountable without trying to diagnose what may be happening in her personal life.
They also help a self-employed listener caught between too much work and no work at all. The conversation moves from self-worth and breadwinner identity to practical ways to steady a business, including defining an ideal client, building recurring revenue, using slow periods to work on the business, and refusing the clients you already know you will resent.
Then Blakely answers the question she received at Arcadia: During her years as a CEO, was she actually happy? Her answer opens an honest conversation about ambition, daycare, motherhood, burnout, therapy, and why learning what you need is only the beginning. You still have to practice it.
Before the Sticky Situations, Heather and Blakely recap the conference itself: fly fishing, breathwork, a sound bath mishap, real connection without cell service, and an AI session that pushed them to confront the growing gender gap in AI work.
Key Takeaways:
Why individual output does not automatically make someone a top performer
How special treatment for one employee becomes a culture problem for everyone
Why managers should address observable patterns, not diagnose an employee
How compassion and accountability can exist at the same time
What self-employed people can do during the slow part of a feast-or-famine cycle
Why household worth should not be calculated by who earns more
How ambition and motherhood can both be true without either one being the problem
Why insight from therapy, a retreat, or a breakthrough still requires daily practice
Why women should build AI literacy without giving up the human skills that matter
Please consider sharing this episode and subscribing to the show for more of the career questions women want answered but rarely ask out loud.
Follow Hosts:
Follow Not All Business:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/notallbiz/
Substack: https://notallbusiness.substack.com/
Links & Mentions:
Arcadia Leadership Experience: https://www.arcadialeadershipexperience.com/ (the Bozeman leadership gathering where this episode’s audience questions originated)
Brian Sowards: https://www.linkedin.com/in/brian-sowards-41456731b (led the “AI Backpack” session that became an open conversation about using AI as a collaborative tool)
LinkedIn research on women in AI hiring: https://news.linkedin.com/2026/new-linkedin-research-finds-women-account-for-just-26-percent-of-ai-hires-as-ai-jobs-surge
Lauren Goodell of Clustr Innovations: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lauren-goodell (helps sales teams adopt AI without losing the judgment, empathy, and human connection the technology cannot replace)
Shannon Hawley, breathwork and sound bath facilitator: https://songandsoundhealing.com/
Submit Your Sticky Situations:
Got a sticky situation for Not All Business? Send an email or voice recording to sticky@notallbusiness.com or drop your question in the comments.
Thank You to Our Sponsors:
Face Five Acne Clinic, Root-Cause Acne Care, No Harsh Prescriptions Required: https://facefiveacne.com - code NOTALLBIZ10 for 10% off your first order
Follow Face Five Skincare: https://www.instagram.com/facefiveskincare/
Follow Wellness with Yuki: https://www.instagram.com/wellnesswithyuki/
Follow Us:
